Barely a month after the #EndSARS protest against police
brutality which turned bloody with loss of lives and massive
destruction of property, the police, which was the main target
of the mayhem is yet to recover. Policemen virtually
disappeared from the public space. The Inspector General of
Police had to issue a directive asking his men to return to the
streets but investigations across the country revealed that
things have not returned to normal. Policemen who are
supposed to protect the residents are themselves afraid to
walk freely on the streets in their uniform. Their morale is low
and they are yet to regain their confidence. In some places,
criminals have taken advantage of the absence of the police
which has resulted in upsurge of crimes.
Ondo
Findings by Saturday Vanguard showed that police personnel
are not fully back on the streets in Ondo state for fear of
possible attack. Some of the policemen who spoke on
condition of anonymity said that they still lived in fear and
could not walk freely on the streets.
According to them, after the protest many of us cant put on
our uniform and walk freely on the streets because of the fear
that we may be attacked. Two of our men were killed during
the protest. One was roasted alive just because the
protesters saw his police uniform inside his car. What we do
now is that when we leave the police station we would
remove our police uniform and put on mufti to disguise.
Speaking with vanguard, the police spokesperson in the state
Tee Leo Ikoro said policemen in the state returned to their
duty posts after the protests. We returned to our duty posts
immediately after the #EndSARS carnage where we lost our
men to the hoodlums. This is because we know our duty is
sacrosanct and if we are off duty many people and things will
be affected. We looked at the #EndSARS saga as a bye gone
but as human as we are, we also felt bad about what
happened and we are aggrieved over the killing of some of our
officers. People expected us not to return to our duty post but
we remain at out duty posts. The #EndSARS protest only
energised us to do more.
Oyo
In Oyo State, only a handful of policemen were at work as
most of the police stations were locked up. Some of the
policemen resumed duty this week even as residents,
government, Yoruba leaders have made passionate pleas to
the policemen to resume duties.
At most junctions where they used to control traffic, men of
the Oyo State Transport management were there to fill the
space. At the UI-Sango-Bodija junction, Mokola, Eleyele,
Ologuneru, some soldiers and members of the state road
transportation management were controlling the traffic.
Traffic wardens were at the Bodija-Cementry junction,
Iyaganku, Bodija market, Oke Ado market.
But, in the area of maintaining security, it appeared the
policemen were not responding to distress calls.
Hoodlums have capitalized on the absence of policemen as
they robbed residents in different parts of the city. At Idi-
Ishin-NIHORT area, a man was shot dead by robbers on a
motorcycle who attempted to snatch the bike.
Edo
It has been a horrible situation in Benin City, Edo state capital
and some other parts of the state since #EndSARS protest
turned violent with the destruction of police facilities and
carting away of arms and ammunition. Rival cult groups
renewed their clashes that have claimed not less than 37
lives, while criminals and hoodlums have taken over the
streets of Benin City. Robberies and other violent crimes have
become a daily occurrence in all parts of Benin City, as people
now live in fear while night life is completely dead as
everybody runs home at dusk. Even residents in Government
Reservation Areas which are so called protected areas are not
spared of these attacks as a guest house less than 500
metres from the gate of government house was recently
ransacked and all the 13 occupants were robbed that night.
The attack on police stations has dampened the morale of
policemen as they disappeared from the streets while those
who still ventured around, moved in mufti. Some of them in
mufti were also victims of robberies as one of them who was
going home after work, had his bag where he kept his service
pistol snatched by suspected robbers in a white Toyota Sienna
bus.
A policeman in Benin confided in Saturday Vanguard that our
morale is very low after that incident. Imagine DPOs now
reporting from the state command everyday and no vehicles
for them and their personnel to work, that is disheartening.
Look at the Area Commander and two of his men who went on
patrol last week and were shot by those hoodlums in Upper
Sokponba. Till now many of us still dont wear our uniforms on
the streets for fear of being attacked. Though the Inspector
General of Police has come to address us, the governor
himself has visited and tried to motivate us but it is gradual,
we will definitely come back to the streets but you dont
expect it to be immediate
The absence of the police on the streets have also resulted in
cases of self help by residents who have turned themselves
into vigilance groups. There was a reported case of two
suspected thieves who were arrested in Upper Sokponba road,
beaten to pulp and set ablaze while in some other areas like
Amagba, Ekheuan Road, residents formed vigilance groups
and take turns to watch all entry and exit points into their
areas.
The commissioner of police in the state, Johnson Kokumo said
the return of the police to their normal duties would be a
gradual process after suffering the damages to their facilities
which he said killed their morale. He said some of the escapee
prisoners were sending threat messages to policemen who
arrested and investigated them before their eventual
prosecution and conviction. Kokumo said his men were
working within existing limitations to restore normalcy to the
state.
He said: You can imagine what it means that three police
stations along Sokponba road were destroyed and burnt;
patrol vehicles destroyed in several other parts of the state
capital, all the officers in these stations now operate from
the headquarters. How do you expect things to be normal in a
place where 2000 inmates escaped? Is there any magic we
can do without vehicles, without arms and ammunition? We
were doing our best to arrest the criminals in Edo before the
jail break and we are equally trying our best to see that the
escapees are re-arrested and brought to book.
Plateau
Despite the fact that there was no attack on the Police in
Plateau State, the presence of the personnel of the Force is
not very visible on the highways and streets in the Jos and
Bukuru metropolis.
Saturday Vanguard observed that spots where the personnel
were always seen mounting road blocks have been free since
the state government lifted the curfew which was imposed in
the Jos North and Jos South local government areas but
traffic police were on their duty posts at major junctions in
the city directing traffic.
Personnel who spoke on condition of anonymity claimed they
followed instructions of their superiors. A police Corporal
serving in the C Division of the Force in Jos said, What
happened when the hoodlums hijacked the #EndSARS protest
was a terrible thing, although we did not experience any
attack here in Jos but we worked based on instruction. We are
not off the roads but sometime when there were no
operational vehicles, we allowed the team on critical
assignment to use the available vehicle to carry out their
duties. You dont expect us to trek from the station to the
road, the demand for work tools for the Police is a very valid
one because we really lack things that can enhance our job.
Another personnel, a Sergeant at the Anglo Jos station added,
We did not experience any attack here but we have to stay
alive first before we combat crime.
Ekiti
Barely a month after the attack on policemen and their offices
by some hoodlums who hijacked the #EndSARS protest in
Ekiti State policemen have gradually been returning to their
duty posts following the intervention of the State Governor,
Dr Kayode Fayemi who visited the state headquarters of the
Ekiti State Police Command to pacify the leadership and men
of the command with a promise to re-build damaged police
stations and compensate victims of the attack. During the
violent protest, several police officers were assaulted and
injured while their personal property including vehicles were
destroyed. Three police stations were set ablaze in Ikere Ekiti
while several weapons were carted away.
Immediately after the unrest, many officers irrespective of
their ranks went into hiding for safety of their lives while
some had no office to resume to due to the destruction. No
single patrol vehicle was sighted on the road except escort
teams of VIPs a situation that gave rise to an increase in
criminal activities and lawlessness in the state.
The issue became so alarming that the Ogoga of Ikere Ekiti
summoned a town hall meeting where he cried out on the
absence of policemen on the streets of the town. However,
the situation has changed as many of the police officers have
returned to their usual place of primary assignments
Speaking with vanguard correspondent, the Ekiti State Police
Public Relations Officer, ASP Sunday Abutu explained that
the police officers are more combatant than ever before to do
their job professionally. According to Abutu, many officers
affected by the violent protest have moved on with their lives
saying most of them have been consoled by the message of
the IGP after the attack.
In a chat, a police officer who spoke on the condition of
anonymity claimed that the protest and attack against the
police did not go down well with most of them. He said, we
were not happy that despite all we have done to protect
people day and night, all they could do was to attack, kill and
destroy our property. We are not the major cause of the
problem, the police too are suffering, we have a lot of
underneath problems we are facing but who do we run to? We
have been working under an abnormal situation, I wonder how
you expect the best from a man that has been subjected to
poor accommodation, irregular allowances, and lack of working
tools. The public can not do without police, we just need to
manage ourselves and continue to endure until the right
things are done by the concerned authorities.
Adamawa
A high ranking retired Police Officer, who spoke on condition
of anonymity in Yola, Adamawa state argued that it would
take the Nigerian Police some months or years to recover
from the trauma of the last #EndSARS protest. Speaking
against the backdrop of the absence of policemen on the
streets of Adamawa state after the protest, he said, though
no police station was destroyed or police personnel killed in
Adamawa during the protest, but what happened in other
states speak volume.
Policemen with their rifles were being chased and killed right
in their stations and on the streets by armed protesters. They
were killed and maimed and they could not defend
themselves. And few months after the orgy of killings, you
expect them to return to the streets and move freely like
before? The Inspector General of Police has directed them to
return to the streets, but he is not everywhere to protect the
policemen. Policemen are human beings like us with families
to take care of and if they recall what happened to their
colleagues elsewhere, it will take time for them to regain their
confidence.
The usual police presence on the streets in Adamawa was
drastically reduced. Policemen were only seen in groups being
moved in their vehicles to their places of work or duty posts.
Other policemen who moved from place to place, may either
be going to work or returning from duty while hiding their
uniforms to shield their identity. The absence of policemen on
the streets and highways has actually resulted in the upsurge
of crimes in the state.
Most of the highways in the state today are no go areas,
especially at nights. The roads are no longer safe, even the
cities are equally affected by the absence of the police on the
streets as armed robbers and other criminals are on the
prowl.
Some of the policemen spoken to expressed regret that the
police was entirely reduced to nothing during the EndSARS
Saga. They argued that though no policeman or station was
attacked in the state as in other states, but what affects one
affects the other. They said many of our colleagues were
killed in the guise of protest while others were maimed. It will
surely take the police a long time to come to terms with the
unfortunate protest and the killings associated with it, but
with time we will adjust to the situation since we have signed
to protect lives and property of the citizenry some of the
police personnel added.
VANGUARD
We will design a series of strategies and tactics that will keep them healthy and make sure that when they seek health care, it is of high quality and very efficient. Population health is defining and managing whatever strategies and tactics are applied to this group. They are intended to achieve certain health care quality, cost, and person-experience goals.
In a way, population health is like being an educator. An educator would formulate an approach to teach a class of 10-year-olds a particular subject, an approach that achieves certain goals of subject comprehension.
Population health complements individual health care delivery, which occurs when youre in front of your doctor or nurse. It also complements public health. Public health says, I want to take steps to ensure the health of the community; for example, that the waters safe and people are being immunized. You can imagine the Venn diagrams that illustrate overlaps between population health, individual care, and public health.
The reason it matters and population health has been around for decades is that health care is in the early stages of a multidecade, fairly significant shift in the business model of care delivery. The shift is largely driven by the fact that medical care costs so much, and continues to cost so much, consuming an amazing amount of the GDP. Its also pretty uneven in terms of quality.
How has the business model changed? Its moving from reactive sick care youre sick, you show up, we take care of you to the proactive management of health, where Im going to reach out and keep you healthy. Its moving from fragmented, disconnected care to integrated care across the continuum from a doctors office to a hospital to rehab to end-of-life, etc. Its moving from a fee-for-service model, where Im going to pay you for volume and activity, to a model in which the doctor and hospital are paid on results the quality and efficiency of care. This business model shift is being driven by reimbursement change, largely from the federal government, but also state and private-sector purchasers of care.
Partners Healthcare System Inc., for example, is incentivized for doing a great job of managing the health of a population of people with diabetes or a population of children with asthma. Theyll receive a certain amount per person, per child, per year to cover all the costs of the care. If they spend less than the amount, they keep the difference. If they spend more than the amount, they experience a loss. Regardless of financial performance, they must achieve certain quality-of-care and health-status metrics.
A range of IT resources is needed to help manage the health of a population. There is a significant need for data about the health of the population to be managed.
If I want to hold you financially and clinically accountable for the care and health of 100,000 people with dementia, youll ask, Well, who are they? I have to know who they are and be able to characterize them. How far along are they in their dementia? Are they poor? Where do they live? Do they have a spouse or a caregiver who can help them out? Do they speak English? To characterize them, I need all kinds of data. I need electronic health record data, but I also need social determinants of health data. I must gather all this information and then make sure Mrs. Smith in one electronic health record is (or isnt) the same Mrs. Smith in another electronic health record, because theres no unifying number here that links people across the board.
Having done that, I ask, Whats the plan to manage Mrs. Smiths health and health care? How do I take care of these people? I can turn to a blue-ribbon panel of doctors to get a core plan for a particular disease, but once I get that plan or that algorithm, I have to lay it over the data, tailor the plan to reflect Mrs. Smiths needs and capabilities, and look for deviations from the plan. I might say, Im going to plan to manage Mrs. Smiths dementia, but last night her spouse passed away, and suddenly my plan has to be revised, because I was counting on that person to help out and I cant anymore. Or Mrs. Smith had a car accident, and she shouldnt have been driving, but she was, and was critically hurt. Suddenly my plan is different.
I must have a plan, and then I must monitor deviations that indicate the plan should be revised. And I should also determine how well the plan is working. What are my measures of quality and efficiency? Am I keeping Mrs. Smith out of assisted living, or should she be in assisted living?
You cant make these decisions without IT to aggregate the data to characterize someone, to determine what the plan is and whether it needs to be altered, and then to generate a series of metrics that say, Im doing OK or Im not doing OK at managing the health of the population.
To help define and manage the plan, we must have care managers. They work for a health system (or an employer or a state Medicaid department), and theyre making sure the plan is working and take steps to remove barriers to the plan. For example, we will have people who are poor or who cant drive, so we have to get them a ride. Or they live in what we call a nutritional wasteland. Theres nothing but liquor stores and convenience stores around them, so if we want them to lose weight, we must get them Meals on Wheels or something along those lines. We should have IT applications for care managers who are committed to making the plan work.
In a lot of cases, to stay healthy, patients must manage themselves. They must manage their weight, make changes to a sedentary lifestyle, and monitor a disease such as congestive heart failure. I need a variety of technologies in the home and through social media to help people stay engaged in managing their health.
Although the changes are driven by reimbursement, you cant manage the health of a population without a viable set of sophisticated IT.
BIG IDEA: DIGITAL LEADERSHIPExperimenting With Artificial Intelligence in Health Care
One health care provider looks to bring artificial intelligence to patient care.
MIT Sloan Management Review: I saw your title, vice president for population health, and I was curious to know a little more about it. What does it mean to be the vice president of population health, and what is population health?
John Glaser: Lets start out with what population health is, and then move to why it matters. Basically, population health centers on a group of individuals who share a common health challenge or health situation. They might all be going through cancer, or they all have spouses with dementia, or theyre all 25 and really healthy and you just want to keep them healthy. But they have a common health challenge or characteristic.
We will design a series of strategies and tactics that will keep them healthy and make sure that when they seek health care, it is of high quality and very efficient. Population health is defining and managing whatever strategies and tactics are applied to this group. They are intended to achieve certain health care quality, cost, and person-experience goals.
In a way, population health is like being an educator. An educator would formulate an approach to teach a class of 10-year-olds a particular subject, an approach that achieves certain goals of subject comprehension.
Population health complements individual health care delivery, which occurs when youre in front of your doctor or nurse. It also complements public health. Public health says, I want to take steps to ensure the health of the community; for example, that the waters safe and people are being immunized. You can imagine the Venn diagrams that illustrate overlaps between population health, individual care, and public health.
The reason it matters and population health has been around for decades is that health care is in the early stages of a multidecade, fairly significant shift in the business model of care delivery. The shift is largely driven by the fact that medical care costs so much, and continues to cost so much, consuming an amazing amount of the GDP. Its also pretty uneven in terms of quality.
How has the business model changed? Its moving from reactive sick care youre sick, you show up, we take care of you to the proactive management of health, where Im going to reach out and keep you healthy. Its moving from fragmented, disconnected care to integrated care across the continuum from a doctors office to a hospital to rehab to end-of-life, etc. Its moving from a fee-for-service model, where Im going to pay you for volume and activity, to a model in which the doctor and hospital are paid on results the quality and efficiency of care. This business model shift is being driven by reimbursement change, largely from the federal government, but also state and private-sector purchasers of care.
Partners Healthcare System Inc., for example, is incentivized for doing a great job of managing the health of a population of people with diabetes or a population of children with asthma. Theyll receive a certain amount per person, per child, per year to cover all the costs of the care. If they spend less than the amount, they keep the difference. If they spend more than the amount, they experience a loss. Regardless of financial performance, they must achieve certain quality-of-care and health-status metrics.
Email Updates on Digital Culture & Strategy
Get monthly email updates on platforms, digital leadership, digital transformation, and ethics.
SUBSCRIBE
Privacy Policy
To what extent is this shift toward population health made possible by digital technologies? You see this issue now with data analytics and electronic health records.
A range of IT resources is needed to help manage the health of a population. There is a significant need for data about the health of the population to be managed.
If I want to hold you financially and clinically accountable for the care and health of 100,000 people with dementia, youll ask, Well, who are they? I have to know who they are and be able to characterize them. How far along are they in their dementia? Are they poor? Where do they live? Do they have a spouse or a caregiver who can help them out? Do they speak English? To characterize them, I need all kinds of data. I need electronic health record data, but I also need social determinants of health data. I must gather all this information and then make sure Mrs. Smith in one electronic health record is (or isnt) the same Mrs. Smith in another electronic health record, because theres no unifying number here that links people across the board.
Having done that, I ask, Whats the plan to manage Mrs. Smiths health and health care? How do I take care of these people? I can turn to a blue-ribbon panel of doctors to get a core plan for a particular disease, but once I get that plan or that algorithm, I have to lay it over the data, tailor the plan to reflect Mrs. Smiths needs and capabilities, and look for deviations from the plan. I might say, Im going to plan to manage Mrs. Smiths dementia, but last night her spouse passed away, and suddenly my plan has to be revised, because I was counting on that person to help out and I cant anymore. Or Mrs. Smith had a car accident, and she shouldnt have been driving, but she was, and was critically hurt. Suddenly my plan is different.
I must have a plan, and then I must monitor deviations that indicate the plan should be revised. And I should also determine how well the plan is working. What are my measures of quality and efficiency? Am I keeping Mrs. Smith out of assisted living, or should she be in assisted living?
You cant make these decisions without IT to aggregate the data to characterize someone, to determine what the plan is and whether it needs to be altered, and then to generate a series of metrics that say, Im doing OK or Im not doing OK at managing the health of the population.
To help define and manage the plan, we must have care managers. They work for a health system (or an employer or a state Medicaid department), and theyre making sure the plan is working and take steps to remove barriers to the plan. For example, we will have people who are poor or who cant drive, so we have to get them a ride. Or they live in what we call a nutritional wasteland. Theres nothing but liquor stores and convenience stores around them, so if we want them to lose weight, we must get them Meals on Wheels or something along those lines. We should have IT applications for care managers who are committed to making the plan work.
In a lot of cases, to stay healthy, patients must manage themselves. They must manage their weight, make changes to a sedentary lifestyle, and monitor a disease such as congestive heart failure. I need a variety of technologies in the home and through social media to help people stay engaged in managing their health.
Although the changes are driven by reimbursement, you cant manage the health of a population without a viable set of sophisticated IT.
You talked about this as a multidecade business-model shift. What have been the challenges that the health care industry or hospitals have faced with respect to digitalization, and are those going to be the same challenges theyre going to face going forward?
One of the challenges, if you go back six or seven years ago, would be that the electronic health record adoption was small, but now its not. Meaningful Use, a Medicare incentive program, has driven this. There has been a lot of progress in adoption.
The next thing we need is the fluid exchange of data between electronic health records data interoperability. Thats made some modest progress, but we still have a ways to go before the data about a patient really flows appropriately and efficiently.
The third challenge is gathering and interpreting data about the social components of health. Were still learning which sets of data really matter in which circumstances. For example, if we want you to get your 10,000 steps a day, what data should we gather to determine the likelihood that you will achieve that goal? For example, how do we motivate people? There are different ways to do it, but I need a set of data to define a motivational construct.
But perhaps the greatest challenge is that we must turn to a series of doctors and say, You guys have to do a much better job of managing the health of people. And they respond, Listen, we actually arent always very good at doing that. We know how to take care of them when theyre sick, but we were never trained to manage health, and were not well equipped to do that. To help caregivers manage health, we need care managers, links to social services and resources, new support processes, and a series of IT investments. The biggest challenge is making this transformation.
Theres a big cultural change, a big education change, and a series of process changes that must go on in health care that are difficult. The industry is beginning to go through that. As often happens with industry transformations, these changes are occurring while people and organizations are under great pressure to perform today under the old business model.
And then frankly its still not clear that if you do all this population health work, you really will bend the cost curve. Medicare has come up with dozens of different population health models and organizational arrangements. Which ones will be the winners? Were still experimenting with different organizational and reimbursement models. Weve got a lot of transformation work left to do, and thats why I think itll take decades.
There are several. But regarding digital ones, we see a whole lot of desire and were not alone for data scientists. The phrase data scientist is fuzzy and has many meanings. In this case, health care needs people who will help providers when they say, Tell me what the data means and whether Im doing a good job or not. Help me think through which data from this long list of social determinants of health I should really be gathering and has significant explanatory power. How do I get this data? How do I deal with uneven data quality? What are the best practices in sharing this data with patients?
Moreover, whos the doctor responsible for Mrs. Smith when she sees seven doctors? Often elderly people do see seven (or more) doctors. But which one do I hold accountable for her care?
Many skills are needed, but the biggest one is professionals who can help caregivers work their way through the data and analytics.
The future is now and a hotel in Japan is leading the way, replacing staff with holograms and robots.
At the Henn-na Hotel, located in Tokyo’s buzzing Ginza district, you’ll be greeted by anything from a female robot, a friendly ninja (who can speak five languages), to an even friendlier dinosaur who is pretty damn excited to meet a human.
The rooms themselves are unfortunately, or fortunately, not holographic but are clean and compact. They’re fitted out with comfy beds (double or twins), modern furnishings, views of Ginza and of course, all the mod cons one could hope for.
Here, the room’s smartphone is your best friend. From it you can operate the TV, control the room temp, set the lighting to everything from sunset to spring, it can even open your front door! There’s also a robotic steam press that removes wrinkles and odours, so you’ll always be looking your freshest. You can use the phone throughout your stay, including data and one free international phone call so you can facetime your bestie with the dinosaur.
If you find yourself craving some human interaction, head down to the lobby and order a quirky cocktail from a pre-paid machine—it will be delivered by a real life human!
A night at the Henn-na Hotel is surprisingly cheap (probably because they can cut back on staff costs) from just $85 a night. If you don’t want to travel as far as Japan, the company behind Henn-na have revealed plans to open more than 100 properties worldwide over the next five years—so you’ll having a dinosaur-staffed hotel coming your way in no time.
Source: Urban list